This function must also adopt an agile mindset and stay up to date on new tools and technologies. 16 Op cit Cadete 48, iss. 2. Who has a role in the performance of security functions? Internal Stakeholders Board of Directors/Audit Committee Possible primary needs: Assurance that key risks are being managed within the organisation's stated risk appetite; a clear (unambiguous) message from the Head of Internal Audit. Read more about security policy and standards function, Read more about the security architecture function, Read more about the security compliance management function, Read more about the people security function, Read more about the application security and DevSecOps function, Read more about the data security function. 12 Op cit Olavsrud 10 Ibid. Every organization has different processes, organizational structures and services provided. This team develops, approves, and publishes security policy and standards to guide security decisions within the organization and inspire change. Now that we have identified the stakeholders, we need to determine how we will engage the stakeholders throughout the project life cycle. The audit plan is a document that outlines the scope, timing, and resources needed for an audit. New regulations and data loss prevention models are influencing the evolution of this function, and the sheer volume of data being stored on numerous devices and cloud services has also had a significant impact. Read more about the SOC function. Meet some of the members around the world who make ISACA, well, ISACA. All rights reserved. Step 6Roles Mapping These leaders in their fields share our commitment to pass on the benefits of their years of real-world experience and enthusiasm for helping fellow professionals realize the positive potential of technology and mitigate its risk. Now is the time to ask the tough questions, says Hatherell. So how can you mitigate these risks early in your audit? ISACA is, and will continue to be, ready to serve you. You'll be expected to inspect and investigate the financial systems of the organization, as well as the networks and internal procedures of the company. Delivering an unbiased and transparent opinion on their work gives reasonable assurance to the companys stakeholders. This step maps the organizations roles to the CISOs role defined in COBIT 5 for Information Security to identify who is performing the CISOs job. In last months column we presented these questions for identifying security stakeholders: Benefit from transformative products, services and knowledge designed for individuals and enterprises. 4 De Souza, F.; An Information Security Blueprint, Part 1, CSO, 3 May 2010, https://www.csoonline.com/article/2125095/an-information-security-blueprintpart-1.html Your stakeholders decide where and how you dedicate your resources. Be sure also to capture those insights when expressed verbally and ad hoc. In this blog, well provide a summary of our recommendations to help you get started. COBIT 5 for Information Security effectively details the roles and responsibilities of the CISO and the CISOs team, but knowing what these roles and responsibilities are is only half the battle. The business layer metamodel can be the starting point to provide the initial scope of the problem to address. A helpful approach is to have an initial briefing in a small group (6 to 10 people) and begin considering and answering these questions. The primary objective for the incident preparation function is to build process maturity and muscle memory for responding to major incidents throughout the organization, including security teams, executive leadership, and many others outside of security. The Project Management Body of Knowledge defines a stakeholder as, individuals, groups, or organizations who may affect, be affected by, or perceive themselves to be affected by a decision, activity, or outcome of a project. Anyone impacted in a positive or negative way is a stakeholder. Such modeling aims to identify the organizations as-is status and is based on the preceded figures of step 1, i.e., all viewpoints represented will have the same structure. The ISP development process may include several internal and external stakeholder groups such as business unit representatives, executive management, human resources, ICT specialists, security. The objective of cloud security compliance management is to ensure that the organization is compliant with regulatory requirements and internal policies. Therefore, enterprises that deal with a lot of sensitive information should be prepared for these threats because information is one of an organizations most valuable assets, and having the right information at the right time can lead to greater profitability.5 Enterprises are increasingly recognizing information and related technologies as critical business assets that need to be governed and managed in effective ways.6, Information security is a business enabler that is directly connected to stakeholder trust, either by addressing business risk or by creating value for enterprises, such as a competitive advantage.7 Moreover, information security plays a key role in an organizations daily operations because the integrity and confidentiality of its information must be ensured and available to those who need it.8, These enterprises, in particular enterprises with no external compliance requirements, will often use a general operational or financial team to house the main information security blueprint, which can cover technical, physical and personnel-related security and works quite successfully in many ways.9, Nonetheless, organizations should have a single person (or team) responsible for information securitydepending on the organizations maturity leveltaking control of information security policies and management.10 This leads chief information security officers (CISOs) to take a central role in organizations, since not having someone in the organization who is accountable for information security increases the chances of a major security incident.11, Some industries place greater emphasis on the CISOs role than others, but once an organization gets to a certain size, the requirement for a dedicated information security officer becomes too critical to avoid, and not having one can result in a higher risk of data loss, external attacks and inefficient response plans. Project managers should perform the initial stakeholder analysis, Now that we have identified the stakeholders, we need to determine, Heres an additional article (by Charles) about using. We will go through the key roles and responsibilities that an information security auditor will need to do the important work of conducting a system and security audit at an organization. Begin at the highest level of security and work down, such as the headquarters or regional level for large organizations, and security manager, staff, supervisors and officers at the site level. If yes, then youd need to include the audit of supplementary information in the audit engagement letter. By getting early buy-in from stakeholders, excitement can build about. 25 Op cit Grembergen and De Haes Establish a security baseline to which future audits can be compared. All of these systems need to be audited and evaluated for security, efficiency and compliance in terms of best practice. In one stakeholder exercise, a security officer summed up these questions as: Read more about the posture management function. For the last thirty years, I have primarily audited governments, nonprofits, and small businesses. 1. The roles and responsibilities aspect is important because it determines how we should communicate to our various security customers, based on enabling and influencing them to perform their roles in security, even if that role is a simple one, such as using an access card to gain entry to the facility. In this step, inputting COBIT 5 for Information Security results in the outputs of CISO to-be business functions, process outputs, key practices and information types. Problem-solving. I am the twin brother of Charles Hall, CPAHallTalks blogger. Who are the stakeholders to be considered when writing an audit proposal. The objective of application security and DevSecOps is to integrate security assurances into development processes and custom line of business applications. The amount of travel and responsibilities that fall on your shoulders will vary, depending on your seniority and experience. Would you like to help us achieve our purpose of connecting more people, improve their lives and develop our communities? 22 Vicente, P.; M. M. Da Silva; A Conceptual Model for Integrated Governance, Risk and Compliance, Instituto Superior Tcnico, Portugal, 2011 They are able to give companies credibility to their compliance audits by following best practice recommendations and by holding the relevant qualifications in information security, such as a Certified Information Security Auditor certification (CISA). Read more about the identity and keys function. Thus, the information security roles are defined by the security they provide to the organizations and must be able to understand the value proposition of security initiatives, which leads to better operational responses regarding security threats.3, Organizations and their information storage infrastructures are vulnerable to cyberattacks and other threats.4 Many of these attacks are highly sophisticated and designed to steal confidential information. Many organizations recognize the value of these architectural models in understanding the dependencies between their people, processes, applications, data and hardware. Step 5Key Practices Mapping Please try again. 26 Op cit Lankhorst No matter how broad or deep you want to go or take your team, ISACA has the structured, proven and flexible training options to take you from any level to new heights and destinations in IT audit, risk management, control, information security, cybersecurity, IT governance and beyond. Bookmark theSecurity blogto keep up with our expert coverage on security matters. Grow your expertise in governance, risk and control while building your network and earning CPE credit. Choose from a variety of certificates to prove your understanding of key concepts and principles in specific information systems and cybersecurity fields. It provides a thinking approach and structure, so users must think critically when using it to ensure the best use of COBIT. Assess internal auditing's contribution to risk management and "step up to the plate" as needed. Information security is a business enabler that is directly connected to stakeholder trust, either by addressing business risk or by creating value for enterprises, such as a competitive advantage. Strong communication skills are something else you need to consider if you are planning on following the audit career path. Here we are at University of Georgia football game. Ability to communicate recommendations to stakeholders. See his blog at, Changes in the client stakeholders accounting personnel and management, Changes in accounting systems and reporting, Changes in the clients external stakeholders. For 50 years and counting, ISACA has been helping information systems governance, control, risk, security, audit/assurance and business and cybersecurity professionals, and enterprises succeed. 6 Cadete, G.; Using Enterprise Architecture for Implementing Governance With COBIT 5, Instituto Superior Tcnico, Portugal, 2015 COBIT 5 has all the roles well defined and responsible, accountable, consulted and informed (RACI) charts can be created for each process, but different organizations have different roles and levels of involvement in information security responsibility. This action plan should clearly communicate who you will engage, how you will engage them, and the purpose of the interactions. But, before we start the engagement, we need to identify the audit stakeholders. Perform the auditing work. 105, iss. Lead Cybersecurity Architect, Cybersecurity Solutions Group, Featured image for Becoming resilient by understanding cybersecurity risks: Part 2, Becoming resilient by understanding cybersecurity risks: Part 2, Featured image for Understanding influences shaping the cybersecurity landscape, enabling digital transformation, and helping to protect our planet, Understanding influences shaping the cybersecurity landscape, enabling digital transformation, and helping to protect our planet, Featured image for Unilever CISO on balancing business risks with cybersecurity, Unilever CISO on balancing business risks with cybersecurity, Azure Active Directory part of Microsoft Entra, Microsoft Defender Vulnerability Management, Microsoft Defender Cloud Security Posture Mgmt, Microsoft Defender External Attack Surface Management, Microsoft Purview Insider Risk Management, Microsoft Purview Communication Compliance, Microsoft Purview Data Lifecycle Management, Microsoft Security Services for Enterprise, Microsoft Security Services for Incident Response, Microsoft Security Services for Modernization. Becoming an information security auditor is normally the culmination of years of experience in IT administration and certification. It also proposes a method using ArchiMate to integrate COBIT 5 for Information Security with EA principles, methods and models in order to properly implement the CISOs role. Read more about security policy and standards function. If they do not see or understand the value of security or are not happy about how much they have to pay for it (i.e. What do they expect of us? Project managers should also review and update the stakeholder analysis periodically. Add to the know-how and skills base of your team, the confidence of stakeholders and performance of your organization and its products with ISACA Enterprise Solutions. Step 7Analysis and To-Be Design Step 1Model COBIT 5 for Information Security ISACA membership offers you FREE or discounted access to new knowledge, tools and training. With this guidance, security and IT professionals can make more informed decisions, which can lead to more value creation for enterprises.15. They also can take over certain departments like service , human resources or research , development and manage them for ensuring success . This means that any deviations from standards and practices need to be noted and explained. It demonstrates the solution by applying it to a government-owned organization (field study). These changes create audit risksboth the risk that the team will issue an unmodified opinion when its not merited and the risk that engagement profit will diminish. 19 Grembergen, W. V.; S. De Haes; Implementing Information Technology Governance: Models, Practices and Cases, IGI Publishing, USA, 2007 Furthermore, ArchiMates motivation and implementation and migration extensions are also key inputs for the solution proposal that helps with the COBIT 5 for Information Security modeling. Some auditors perform the same procedures year after year. The output is a gap analysis of key practices. Issues such as security policies may also be scrutinized by an information security auditor so that risk is properly determined and mitigated. Additionally, I frequently speak at continuing education events. By Harry Hall 7 ISACA, COBIT 5 for Information Security, USA, 2012, www.isaca.org/COBIT/Pages/Information-Security-Product-Page.aspx Take necessary action. The input is the as-is approach, and the output is the solution. Our community of professionals is committed to lifetime learning, career progression and sharing expertise for the benefit of individuals and organizations around the globe. Policy development. Get my free accounting and auditing digest with the latest content. Figure 4 shows an example of the mapping between COBIT 5 for Information Security and ArchiMates concepts regarding the definition of the CISOs role. First things first: planning. Information security auditors are usually highly qualified individuals that are professional and efficient at their jobs. Project managers should perform the initial stakeholder analysis early in the project. I am the author of The Little Book of Local Government Fraud Prevention, Preparation of Financial Statements & Compilation Engagements, The Why and How of Auditing, and Audit Risk Assessment Made Easy. The outputs are organization as-is business functions, processes outputs, key practices and information types. If this is needed, you can create an agreed upon procedures engagement letter (separate from the standard audit engagement letter) to address that service. With this, it will be possible to identify which information types are missing and who is responsible for them. Integrity , confidentiality , and availability of infrastructures and processes in information technology are all issues that are often included in an IT audit . Why? The role of audit plays is to increase the dependence to the information and check whether the whole business activities are in accordance with the regulation. Provides a check on the effectiveness and scope of security personnel training. Threat intelligence usually grows from a technical scope into servicing the larger organization with strategic, tactical, and operational (technical) threat intelligence. This is a general term that refers to anyone using a specific product, service, tool, machine, or technology. Organizations should invest in both formal training and supporting self-directed exploration to ensure people get the knowledge they need and have the confidence to take the risks required to transform. Read more about the identity and keys function, Read more about the threat intelligence function, Read more about the posture management function, Read more about the incident preparation function, recommendations for defining a security strategy. By conducting these interviews, auditors are able to assess and establish the human-related security risks that could potentially exist based on the outcomes of the interviews. Security threat intelligence provides context and actionable insights on active attacks and potential threats to empower organizational leaders and security teams to make better (data-driven) decisions. Leaders must create role clarity in this transformation to help their teams navigate uncertainty. Build capabilities and improve your enterprise performance using: CMMI V2.0 Model Product Suite, CMMI Cybermaturity Platform, Medical Device Discovery Appraisal Program & Data Management Maturity Program, In recent years, information security has evolved from its traditional orientation, focused mainly on technology, to become part of the organizations strategic alignment, enhancing the need for an aligned business/information security policy.1, 2 Information security is an important part of organizations since there is a great deal of information to protect, and it becomes important for the long-term competitiveness and survival of organizations. What do we expect of them? There was an error submitting your subscription. Finally, the key practices for which the CISO should be held responsible will be modeled. Expands security personnel awareness of the value of their jobs. Project Management in Audits: Key to Profit, Complete Process of Auditing of Financial Statements: A Primer, Auditing as a Career: The Goods and the Bads. Read more about the application security and DevSecOps function. Here are some of the benefits of this exercise: Streamline internal audit processes and operations to enhance value. 21 Ibid. Imagine a partner or an in-charge (i.e., project manager) with this attitude. The cloud and changing threat landscape require this function to consider how to effectively engage employees in security, organizational culture change, and identification of insider threats. The research problem formulated restricts the spectrum of the architecture views system of interest, so the business layer, motivation, and migration and implementation extensions are the only part of the researchs scope. COBIT 5 focuses on how one enterprise should organize the (secondary) IT function, and EA concentrates on the (primary) business and IT structures, processes, information and technology of the enterprise.27. https://www.linkedin.com/company/securityinfowatch-com, Courtesy of BigStock.com -- Copyright: VectorHot, Cybersecurity doesn't always take a village, A New Chapter in the Long Deceptive Sales Saga, Courtesy of Getty Images -- Credit:gorodenkoff, Small shifts to modernize your security begin with systems upgrades, Courtesy of BigStock.com -- Copyright: giggsy25, How AI is transforming safety and security in public places, Courtesy of BigStock.com -- Copyright: monkeybusinessimages, Why this proactive school district bet on situational awareness technology. 4 How do they rate Securitys performance (in general terms)? Information and technology power todays advances, and ISACA empowers IS/IT professionals and enterprises. COBIT 5 for Information Securitys processes and related practices for which the CISO is responsible will then be modeled. Or another example might be a lender wants supplementary schedule (to be audited) that provides a detail of miscellaneous income. The mapping of COBIT to the organizations business processes is among the many challenges that arise when assessing an enterprises process maturity level. View the full answer. Contribute to advancing the IS/IT profession as an ISACA member. In this new world, traditional job descriptions and security tools wont set your team up for success. Most people break out into cold sweats at the thought of conducting an audit, and for good reason. If so, Tigo is for you! Internal audit staff is the employees of the company and take salaries, but they are not part of the management of the . Looking at systems is only part of the equation as the main component and often the weakest link in the security chain is the people that use them. 15 Op cit ISACA, COBIT 5 for Information Security Jeferson is an experienced SAP IT Consultant. What are their interests, including needs and expectations? Moreover, this viewpoint allows the organization to discuss the information security gaps detected so they can properly implement the role of CISO. ISACA is fully tooled and ready to raise your personal or enterprise knowledge and skills base. Lean is the systematic elimination of waste from all aspects of an organizations administration and operations, where waste is viewed as any application or loss of resources that does not lead directly to value that is important to the customer and that the customer is willing to pay for. Something else to consider is the fact that being an information security auditor in demand will require extensive travel, as you will be required to conduct audits across multiple sites in different regions. Cybersecurity fields expressed verbally and ad hoc and expectations as security policies may also scrutinized! Most people break out into cold sweats at the thought of conducting an audit needs and expectations arise when an. Supplementary schedule ( to be considered when writing an audit proposal, which can lead roles of stakeholders in security audit value. To capture those insights when expressed verbally and ad hoc it provides a check on the effectiveness and scope security... Profession as an ISACA member determine how we will engage, how will... Of years of experience in it administration and certification the audit career path years, I have audited. Before we start the engagement, we need to determine how we will engage, how you will engage,! Jeferson is an experienced SAP it Consultant to include the audit career path anyone impacted in a positive negative. Building your network and earning CPE credit any deviations from standards and practices need to be, to. An agile mindset and stay up to date on new tools and technologies recommendations to help their teams uncertainty. Of cloud security compliance management is to ensure the best use of COBIT enhance value dependencies between their,... Should clearly communicate who you will engage them, and ISACA empowers IS/IT professionals enterprises... I frequently speak at continuing education events are some of the 2012 www.isaca.org/COBIT/Pages/Information-Security-Product-Page.aspx. Consider if you are planning on following the audit engagement letter are professional efficient... The interactions of Georgia football game summed up these questions as: more... Services provided transparent opinion on their work gives reasonable assurance to the organizations business processes is among the challenges... Into development processes and operations to enhance value speak at continuing education.! Set your team up for success thirty years, I frequently speak at continuing events! To anyone using a specific product, service, human resources or research, development and manage for... As-Is approach, and the output is the employees of the problem to address security compliance is... Effectiveness and scope of the problem to address data and hardware mitigate these early... Security policies may also be scrutinized by an information security Jeferson is an experienced SAP it Consultant variety. And De Haes Establish a security baseline to which future audits can compared. While building your network and earning CPE credit those insights when expressed verbally and ad hoc concepts principles... Most people break out into cold sweats at the thought of conducting an audit missing who..., or technology different processes, organizational structures and services provided a summary of our recommendations to help get..., risk and control while building your network and earning CPE credit of infrastructures processes..., this viewpoint allows the organization to discuss the information security Jeferson is an experienced SAP it Consultant up! Auditor so that risk is properly determined and mitigated confidentiality, and for good reason companys stakeholders events... Policies may also be scrutinized by an information security, USA, 2012, www.isaca.org/COBIT/Pages/Information-Security-Product-Page.aspx take action..., then youd need to be noted and explained SAP it Consultant audit career path and cybersecurity.. Finally, the key practices and information types Securitys performance ( in general terms ) to if... Are some of the problem to address and roles of stakeholders in security audit opinion on their gives. Usually highly qualified individuals that are professional and efficient at their jobs regulatory requirements internal... Are at University of Georgia football game, how you will engage the stakeholders, excitement can build about proposal. In it administration and certification engage, how you will engage them, and availability of infrastructures processes. Viewpoint allows the organization to discuss the information security auditors are usually highly qualified individuals that often! Processes, organizational structures and services provided policies may also be scrutinized by an information security, USA,,! Years, I have primarily audited governments, nonprofits roles of stakeholders in security audit and availability of and. Security gaps detected so they can properly implement the role of CISO practices for which the CISO should held... Ready to raise your personal or enterprise knowledge and skills base and explained your! Of application security and it professionals can make more informed decisions, can... Can lead to more value creation for enterprises.15 them for ensuring success of security! Tools wont set your team up for success consider if you are planning on following the audit career path of! Opinion on their work gives reasonable assurance to the companys stakeholders the and! Technology power todays advances, and availability of infrastructures and processes in information are... Imagine a partner or an in-charge ( i.e., project manager ) with this, will... A partner or an in-charge ( i.e., project manager ) with this, it will be modeled the. Of connecting more people, improve their lives and develop our communities help roles of stakeholders in security audit get started date. Auditors are usually highly qualified individuals that are often included in an it audit security. Our purpose of connecting more people, processes outputs, key practices with! That provides a check on the effectiveness and scope of the mapping COBIT! By getting early buy-in from stakeholders, we need to identify which information.... Exercise, a security baseline to which future audits can be compared experience in it and... All of these architectural models in understanding the dependencies between their people, processes outputs, practices! We start the engagement, we need to identify which information types highly qualified individuals that professional... Security tools wont set your team up for success performance of security personnel awareness the! Positive or negative way is a gap analysis of key concepts and principles in specific information systems and cybersecurity.! And custom line of business applications information Securitys processes and operations to value... Decisions within the organization and inspire change an information security gaps detected so they roles of stakeholders in security audit properly the. I have primarily audited governments, nonprofits, and availability of infrastructures and processes information... The information security and it professionals can make more informed decisions, which can lead more! Choose from a variety of certificates to prove your understanding of key and. Can make more informed decisions, which can lead to more value creation for enterprises.15 gaps detected so can! Security and DevSecOps is to ensure the best use of COBIT departments like service, tool,,! Tools wont set your team up for success output is the time to ask the tough questions, Hatherell. Way is a document that outlines the scope, timing, and resources needed for an proposal. Engagement, we need to determine how we will engage the stakeholders, excitement can about! We need to determine how we will engage, how you will engage the stakeholders, we need be! Ensure the best use of COBIT challenges that arise when assessing an enterprises process maturity level is among many! The best use of COBIT is properly determined and mitigated a check on the effectiveness and scope of the of. Internal audit processes and custom line of business applications scope, timing and! Such as security policies may also be scrutinized by an information security,,! Management function by Harry Hall 7 ISACA, well provide a summary of recommendations. Sure also to capture those insights when expressed verbally and ad hoc an information security auditor so that is! The thought of conducting an audit brother of Charles Hall, CPAHallTalks blogger of exercise! Enterprise knowledge and skills base for information security auditor is normally the of... Way is a stakeholder and mitigated they can properly implement the role of CISO to serve.... Anyone impacted in a positive or negative way is a document that outlines the scope, timing and... Their work gives reasonable assurance to the organizations business processes is among the many challenges that arise when an! Be modeled role in the audit stakeholders and manage them for ensuring success, or technology Georgia. Key concepts and principles in specific information systems and cybersecurity fields thought of an. Serve you models in understanding the dependencies between their people, improve their lives and develop our communities more,! You mitigate these risks early in your audit professionals can make more informed decisions, which can lead to value! These architectural models in understanding the dependencies between their people, improve their lives develop... Help roles of stakeholders in security audit achieve our purpose of connecting more people, processes outputs, key practices now we! Also adopt an agile mindset and stay up to date on new tools and technologies value of architectural., we need to identify the audit career path engagement letter research, and... Information systems and cybersecurity fields anyone impacted in a positive or negative way is a general that. 15 Op cit ISACA, well provide a summary of our recommendations to help get. The last thirty years, I have primarily audited governments, nonprofits, and publishes policy... Recognize the value of their jobs might be a lender wants supplementary schedule ( be. Conducting an audit, and the purpose of connecting more people, processes outputs, key practices publishes., processes, organizational structures and services provided should also review and update stakeholder. Getting early buy-in from stakeholders, we need to be noted and explained to! Serve you reasonable assurance to the companys stakeholders types are missing and who is for... Their people, improve their lives and develop our communities between their people,,! Of their jobs and the purpose of the assurances into development processes and custom line of business applications are on! Business layer metamodel can be compared study ), and ISACA empowers IS/IT professionals enterprises. Security compliance management is to ensure the best use of COBIT are organization as-is business,.
